Creamy Dairy-Free Tomato Sauce
Who got a new kitchen gadget for the holidays? Or, just for fun recently? While I’m excited about the new Instant Pot I received for Christmas and all the delicious recipes to come, my favorite kitchen tool for the past couple of years has been my immersion blender, especially when it comes to making creamy recipes like this dairy-free tomato sauce.

I use this in a variety of recipes for several reasons:
- It’s safer than transferring hot liquid/food to a standing blender.
- It can be used with hot liquid batch recipes like soups or for single serve cold recipes like smoothies.
- Dairy-free recipes can be made creamy with a variety of ingredients.
- It doesn’t take up much space.
- Clean-up is faster than with any other kitchen tool.
Dairy-Free Sauces, Soups & More!
Before I started to get more creative, my go-to dairy free creamy recipe was the cashew tomato pasta sauce I’m sharing in this post. Since then, my immersion blender has helped me use not only cashews, but also white beans to give recipes the creamy texture many desire without the dairy.

And, sometimes, using the immersion blender is not about the omission of dairy, but just getting a delicious texture in a soup, chili, or homemade tomato sauce {like this butternut squash and leek soup , red lentil and red pepper chili, or this easy homemade tomato marinara sauce}
Health Benefits of Dairy-Free Tomato Sauce
Now, whether you need to be dairy-free or not doesn’t really matter – variety is not only the spice of life, but is also important to ensure you’re getting a variety of nutrients into your body. The mono-unsaturated fats in nuts like cashews and the fiber you get from white beans are things many Americans are lacking in their regular eating patterns.

While some people like to ignore GI responses to dairy, especially from creams that are used in many of the recipes I reference (lactose intolerance affects up to 2/3 of people!), when it comes to fitness nutrition, most people want to avoid any unpleasant symptoms. Maybe you’ll enjoy a good ole’ classic fettuccine alfredo here and there, but it’s likely something you’d avoid on a regular basis if you know it will impact your workout routine or tomorrow’s race. Plus, the healthy fats here can help balance the body’s inflammation when you eat more of them on a regular basis.
And, as many of you know, while I can’t have dairy, I have a cheese lover in the house who confirms the deliciousness of any recipes before they’re shared on this blog! On the regular, we enjoy sauces like this with bean pastas from brands like Explore, Tolerant and Banza, since they boost protein, fiber and satiety, but sometimes it’s great just to have the traditional version, too.
What’s your favorite kitchen gadget? Share in the comments so that I can cater recipes to you in the future 🙂
Interested in what other cool kitchen gadgets are out there, or have some sitting in the cabinet because you don’t know what to do with them? Click on the Recipe Redux link at the bottom of this post to see what my fellow-bloggers love to make with their favorite kitchen tools!

Creamy Dairy-Free Tomato Sauce
Ingredients
- Easy Homemade Marinara recipe, or your favorite 20-24 ounce jar of tomato sauce
- 1 cup cashews
- 1.5 cups water
Instructions
- Ahead of time, soak cashews in the water for a minimum of 2 hours, by dumping them in a small bowl and filling with water just to cover. An overnight soak is best – the longer you soak, the less time you’ll spend blending and the more creamy the sauce will be.
- Add your sauce to a medium sized pot over low-medium heat. After about 3-5 minutes, stir in the drained cashews and cook an additional 3-5 minutes.
- Submerge the bottom of your immersion blender into the sauce and pulse on low for roughly 10-15 seconds. Increase speed to medium and blend an additional 30-60 seconds, until you reach a creamy consistency to your liking.
- Serve with your favorite pasta, vegetable and protein, or a bean based pasta to cross both the pasta and protein off the list at once.



I love a creamy tomato sauce like this. Cashews are such a magical ingredient.
I know they’re so versatile!
Oh yes! I just got one of these and need to use it!
It’s one of the most fun gadgets to me too – especially since it’s SO easy to clean!
Such a creative idea for cashews in a tomato sauce! Buying some today!!
Cashews are my go-to for cream sauces!!
Yay for immersion blenders!! I really need to go retrieve mine from my parents’ place! I wanna use it more!
What a great way to amp up the nutrition in normal tomato sauce! I love using cashews as a dairy substitute… though I have never thought to use my immersion blender. Great tip – thank you!
There’s still a cashew sauce I make in the vitamix but this works great mixing with tomato sauce when they’re heating up!
This is so easy and I’m sure very yummy!
Oh yum! Love that it’s made from cashews – they are so versatile! 🙂
I love everything about this post! I’m always looking for new creamy non-dairy recipes AND I LOVE using my immersion blender so this is just great 🙂
Hmmm I never thought of adding cashews to make a creamy sauce–genius! And I’ve got a giant can of cashews in the pantry right now!
Wow looks SO flavorful!!
Thanks Stacey!
Another reason to break out my immersion blender! 😀 This sounds awesome Kelly!
Thanks Emily! Love any excuse to use it 🙂
This sauce looks amazing! I’ve been wanting an immersion blender for a while!
Add it to your short list! It’s fun too 🙂
I love my immersion blender and the idea of this creamy sauce! Yum!
I just started using my year old immersion blender and I love it! I’m going to have to try this recipe out, it looks delicious. SO appreciate that it’s dairy-free!
If you are dairy free you’re going to be even happier you got that immersion blender out! Such a great kitchen tool
This looks delicious!!!